Skip to content | Go to list of access keys | Site Map | Contact Us | newzealand.govt.nz

Water hearing

Supplementary Submitter Evidence, Expert Evidence and Legal Submissions Presented at the Hearing

Supplementary Statement Dr McConchie for Palmerston North City Council - Received December 2009
Supplementary Statement of Carmen Taylor for Winstone Pulp International - Received 29 January 2010
Supplementary Statement of Paul Kennedy for Winstone Pulp International - Received 29 January 2010
Legal Submissions for Winstone Pulp International Presented 3 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Graeme Mathieson for AgResearch Ltd and Livestock Improvement Corporation Ltd - Received 8 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Robert Schofield for TrustPower Ltd - Received 9 February 2010
Supplementary Statement of Greg Sneath for NZ Fertiliser Manufacturers’ Research Association Inc, Ballance Agri-Nutrients Limited And Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-Operative Ltd - Received 9 February 2010
Affidavit and Supplementary Evidence of Dr Antony Roberts for Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-Operative Ltd - Received 10 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Christopher Adrian Hansen on Behalf of Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-operative Ltd - Received 10 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Meridian Energy Ltd - Presented 10 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Catherine Clarke for Meridian Energy Ltd - Presented 10 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Keith Hamill for Palmerston North City Council - Received 11 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Andrew Bashford for Palmerston North City Council - Presented on 12 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Palmerston North City Council - Presented 12 February 2010
Summary of Subsmission fron Dr McConchie for Palmerston North City Council - Presented on 12 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Nigel Sadlier for Ballance Agri-Nutrients Limited - Received 12 February 2010
Appendix One to Addendum to Statement of Evidence of Richard Matthews for Genesis Power Ltd – Received 17 February 2010
Addendum to Statement of Evidence of Richard Matthews for Genesis Power Ltd – Received 17 February 2010
Addendum to Statement of Evidence of Jarrod Bowler for Genesis Power Ltd – Received 17 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Dr John Michael Russell for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd - Received 17 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Dr Michael Robert Scarsbrook for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd - Received 17 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Sean Matthew Newland for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd - Received 17 February 2010
Appendix One to Supplementary Evidence of Sean Matthew Newland for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd - Received 17 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Federated Farmers of New Zeland Inc - Presented 17 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Genesis Power Ltd - Presented 18 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of David Forrest for the Territorial Authority Collective - Presented on 18 February 2010
Legal Submissions for TrustPower Ltd - Presented 18 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd - Presented 19 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Arthur Male for Mighty River Power Ltd Presented 24 February 2010
Addendum to Statement of Evidence of Andrew Collins for Mighty River Power Ltd Presented 24 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Mighty River Power Ltd Presented 24 February 2010
Speaking Notes of Emily Grace for NZ Defence Force Received 24 February 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Nathan Baker for Higgins Group Presented 25 February 2010
Evidence of Dave Miller for Manawatu Onsite Wastewater User Group Presented 25 February 2010
Evidence of Hamish Lowe for Manawatu Onsite Wastewater User Group Presented 25 February 2010
Evidence of Hamish Lowe (and attachment) for CPG NZ Presented 25 February 2010
Evidence of Katie Beecroft for CPG NZ (and attachment) Presented 25 February 2010
Evidence of Peter Hill for CPG NZ Presented 25 February 2010
Evidence of Andrew Barber for Horticulture NZ Received 26 February 2010
Legal Submissions for Horticulture NZ Presented 2 March 2010
Evidence of Neil Deans for New Zealand Fish & Game Wellington Region Received 2 March 2010
Dr Mike Joy Fish and Game NZ Well Reg & Royal Forest & Bird Protection Soc of NZ Rec 2 March 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Logan Brown for Minister of Conservation Received 2 March 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Julian Watts for Minister of Conservation Received 3 March 2010
Further Info from Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd following appearance at the Water Hearing on 19 Feb 2010 - Rec 3 March 2010
Supplementary Evidence of Corina Jordan for New Zealand Fish & Game Wellington Region Presented 4 March 2010
Legal Submissions for Minister of Conservation Presented 4 March 2010
Response from FFNZ re Draft Permitted Rules following appearance at the Water Hearing on 17 Feb 2010 - Rec 4 March 2010
Spk Notes Assoc Professor Russell Death for Fish and Game NZ Well Reg & Royal Forest & Bird Protection Soc of NZ Presented 4 March 2010
PowerPoint of Assoc Professor Russell Death for Fish and Game NZ Well Reg & Royal Forest & Bird Protection Soc of NZ Presented 4 March 2010
Draft Rule 13-1 proposed by FGNZ following appearance at the Water Hearing on 3 & 4 March 2010 - Rec 17 March 2010
Combined Position Statement of FGNZ and Royal Forest Bird Protection Soc of NZ on matters relating to Rule 13-1 - Rec 17 March 2010
Response from FGNZ to questions raised at the Water Hearing - Rec 16 March 2010
Position Statement of the Minister of Conservation on matters relating to Rule 13-1 Received 18 March 2010
Supplementary Legal Submission for Federated Farmers of New Zeland Inc - Received 26 March 2010

Water hearing (Water Quality, FARM Strategy, Water Allocation, Groundwater and Beds of Rivers and Lakes)

Summary Table – Outline of experts and Issues of contention from submitters who have been granted a time extension until 19 October 2009

Submitter Evidence for the Water Hearing (Water Quality, FARM Strategy, Water Allocation, Groundwater and Beds of Rivers and Lakes)

Evidence of David LeMarquand for Transpower regarding the Water Quality – Received 28 September 2009
Evidence of David LeMarquand for The Oil Companies regarding the Water Quality – Received 28 September 2009
Evidence of Emily Grace for The NZ Defence Force regarding all topics of the water hearing – Received 28 September 2009
Evidence of Nigel Sadlier for Ballance Agri-Nutrients Limited regarding the FARM strategy and Water Quality topics – Received 28 September 2009
Evidence of Greg Sneath for NZ Fert Manufacturer Research Assoc Re. FARM strategy Water Quality and Groundwater – Received 28 September 2009
Attachment to the Evidence of Greg Sneath for NZ Fert Manufacturer Research Assoc - Report Summary - Wise Use of N Trial
Evidence of Keith Hamill for Palmerston North City Council regarding Water Quality Received 16 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Jack McConchie for Palmerston North City Council regarding Water Quality Received 16 October 2009
Evidence of Chris Pepper for Palmerston North City Council regarding All Water Topics Received 16 October 2009
Evidence of Andrew Bashford for Palmerston North City Council regarding All Water Topics Received 16 October 2009
Appendix 1 to Evidence of Andrew Bashford for Palmerston North City Council Received 16 October 2009
Evidence of Catherine Mary Clarke for Meridian Energy Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Neels Botha for Fish & Game New Zealand Wellington Region regarding FARM Strategy Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Ian Christopher Fuller for Fish & Game New Zealand Wellington Region regarding BRL Receievd 19 October 2009
Evidence of Assoc Professor Russell Death for Fish and Game NZ Well Reg & Royal Forest & Bird Protection Soc of NZ Rec 19 Oct 2009
Evidence of Gary Williams for New Zealand Fish & Game Wellington Region Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Mike Joy Fish and Game NZ Well Reg & Royal Forest & Bird Protection Soc of NZ Received 19 Oct 2009
Evidence of Christopher Adrian Hansen for Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-operative Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Antony Roberts for Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-operative Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Nathan Baker for Higgins Group Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Graeme Mathieson for AgResearch Ltd and Livestock Improvement Corporation Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Robert John Weir for Genesis Power Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Richard Matthews for Genesis Power Ltd Received 20 October 2009
Evidence of Jarrod Bowler for Genesis Power Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Carmen Wendy Taylor for Winstone Pulp International Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Paul Cameron Kennedy for Winstone Pulp International Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Robert John Schofield for TrustPower Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Appendix 1 to Evidence of Robert John Schofield for TrustPower Ltd Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Julian Watts for Minister of Conservation Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Logan Arthur Brown for Minister of Conservation Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Corina Jordan for Fish & Game New Zealand Wellington Region Recevied 19 October 2009
Appendix 1 to Evidence of Corina Jordan for Fish & Game New Zealand Wellington Region Recevied 19 October 2009
Memorandum of Counsel for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Anne-Marie Westcott for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of David James Bridges for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of David James Cameron for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Braden Austin for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Richard Kirby for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of David James Forrest for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Paul Kennedy for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Annette Sweeney for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Appendix to Evidence of Annette Sweeney for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Brendan Duffy for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Appendix to Evidence of Brendan Duffy for the Territorial Authority Collective Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of David James Schumacher for King Country Energy Limited Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of William James Armstrong for King Country Energy Limited Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of David Christopher Fincham for King Country Energy Limited Received 19 October 2009
Evidence of Richard Peterson for Mighty River Power Ltd Received 23 October 2009
Evidence of Andrew Collins for Mighty River Power Ltd Received 23 October 2009
Attachment to Planning Evidence Track Changes to Chapter 6
Attachment to Planning Evidence Track Change Rule 13-23
Attachment to Planning Evidence Track Changes to Chapter 15
Attachment to Planning Evidence Track Changes to Chapter 16
Evidence of Arthur Male for Mighty River Power Ltd Received 23 October 2009
Evidence of Kieran Murray for Mighty River Power Ltd Received 23 October 2009
Evidence of Gerard Matthew Willis for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Dr John Michael Russell for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Terry Graham Parminter for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Sean Matthew Newland for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Duncan Colquhoun Smeaton for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Matthew Glen Newman for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Michael Robert Scarsbrook for Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd Received 30 October 2009
Evidence of Dr Richard Garland and Andrew Lewis for NZ Pharmaceuticals Ltd regarding the Water Quality - Received 28 September 2009
Additional Evidence of Janita Stuart - Received 19 August 2009
Evidence of Paul Horton for Tanenuiarangi Manawatu Incorporated Received 22 October 2009

Submitter Tabled evidence for the Water Hearing (Water Quality, FARM Strategy, Water Allocation, Groundwater and Beds of Rivers and Lakes)

Evidence of Ministry of Education regarding Water Quantity and Water Quality Received 29 September 2009
Evidence of the Poultry Industry Assoc of NZ and Others Received 10 November 2009