Submitter response to the Commissioners Preliminary Decision and Consent Conditions 18 May 2012
Council response to the Commissioners Preliminary Decision 16 May 2012:
s42A Regional Officers Response
Supplementary Evidence - Grey Wilson
Discharge stormwater to land concrete
Earthworks and Vegetation Removal Consent
Streamworks and Reclamation Consent
District Conditions Draft - marked up
Schedule 1 and Tables 1 and 2 of Schedule 1
Schedule 2
Preliminary decision released by the Commissioners on 13 April 2012. Please click here to view a copy of the Preliminary Decision, Appendix 1, Appendix 2.
Genesis Energy Tenth Case Management Memorandum 21 May 2012
Genesis Energy Ninth Case Management Memorandum 17 May 2012
Genesis Energy Eigth Case Management Memorandum 16 May 2012
Genesis Energy Seventh Case Management Memorandum 14 May 2012
Genesis Energy Seventh Case Management Memorandum Figure 1 80M Layout Plan 14 May 2012
Genesis Energy Seventh Case Management Memorandum Figure 2 90M Layout Plan 14 May 2012
Genesis Energy Seventh Case Management Memorandum Figure 3 100L Layout Plan 14 May 2012
Genesis Energy Seventh Case Management Memorandum Figure 4 110L Layout Plan 14 May 2012
Robert and Lucy Thorneycroft Response to Genesis Energy Sixth Case Management 15 May 2012
Genesis Energy Sixth Case Management Memorandum re Preliminary Decision 8 May 2012
Responses to Commissioners Queries F Boffa Response to Minute 7 - 13 March 2012 Genesis Energy 5th Case Management Memo - 13 March 2012 T McKenzie Supplementary Statement - 13 March 2012
Minutes from the hearing panel
Submitter hearing evidence Please click here to view the page containing all submitter evidence
Applicants Landscape and Closing received 20 February 2012 Boffa Figures for Fourth Supplementary Evidence 17 February 2012 Boffa Fourth Supplementary Evidence 17 Feruary 2012 CHWF Project Closing Legal Submissions Air Discharge Permit - 17 February 2012 Discharge fill to land - 17 February 2012 Discharge stormwater to land - 17 February 2012 District Conditions 17 February 2012 Earthworks and vegetation removal consent - 17 February 2012 Horizons Water Take 105953 - 17 February 2012 Horizons Water Take 105954 - 17 February 2012 Mitchell Second Supplementary Evidence 17 February 2012 Schedule 1 and Schedule 2- 17 February 2012 Stormwater discharge permit - 17 February 2012 Streamworks and reclamation consent - 17 February 2012 Tables 1 and 2 of Schedule 1 - 17 Feb 2012 WRC Water Take 31331 - 17 February 2012
Council supplementary evidence most recently received 8 February 2012 Grey Wilson Additional Response Re Conditions 8 February 2012 Supplementary Statement of Evidence - Clive Anstey (substation & power lines) Second supplementary Statement of Evidence - Nigel Robert Lloyd Suggested Conditions - Community Liaison Group 27 January 2012 Bat and Bird Conditions 26 January 2012 Grey Wilson subdivision potential 24 January 2012 Anstey supplementary statement 21 January 2012 Grey Wilson supplementary statement 19 January 2012 Legal statement from Brookfields Lawyers on behalf of Tararua District Council 19 January 2012 Raymond Cannon supplementary statement 19 January 2012 Nigel Lloyd supplementary statement 18 January 2012 Alec Birch supplementary statement 18 January 2012
Applicant supplementary evidence received 10 February 2012 Matthews second supplementary 10 February 2012 Halstead third supplementary 10 February 2012 McKenzie third supplementary 10 February 2012 Seyb third supplementary 10 February 2012 Apeldoorn forth supplementary 10 February 2012 Shaw forth supplementary 10 February 2012
Applicant evidence tabled at reconvened hearing most recently received 26 January 2012 Brantley evidence 24 January 2012
Applicant supplementary evidence most recently received 23 January 2012 Genesis Energy Fourth Case Management Memorandum 23 January 2012 Boffa Third Supplementary Addendum 20 January 2012 Boffa Third Supplementary Statement 11 January 2012 Genesis Energy Third Case Management Memorandum 18 January 2012 Further Legal Submissions 23 December 2011 Amended Proposed Resource Consent Conditions 20 December 2011 Earthworks Caucusing memo final 19 Dec 2011 R Matthews CHWF Supplementary Statement 20 December 2011 T McKenzie CHWF Second Supplementary Statement 20 December 2011 Apeldoorn Third Supplementary Evidence (including figures) 20 December 2011 Boffa Second Supplementary Evidence 20 December 2011 Halstead Second Supplementary Evidence 20 December 2011 Seyb Second Supplementary Evidence 20 December 2011 Shaw Second Supplementary Evidence 20 December 2011 Genesis Energy Second Case Management Memorandum (22 Dec 2011)
Applicant supplementary hearing evidence Armstrong Second Supplementary Evidence Final 21 December 2011 Apeldoorn Second Supplementary Evidence Final 21 December 2011 Apeldoorn Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Armstrong Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Boffa Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 and maps Goldsmith Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Halstead Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 McKenzie Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Mitchell Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Seyb Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Shaw Supplementary Evidence 28 November 2011 Castle Hill Wind Farm opening legal submission 28 November 2011 Case requested by Commissioners during Genesis' opening submissions Council supplementary hearing evidence Freshwater Technical review Response to Evidence 6 December 2011 Outstanding matters Terrestrial Ecology 6 December 2011 Clive Anstey - post caucusing dwellings 6 December 2011 Nigel Lloyd Noise Statement on behalf of Tararua District Council 6 December 2011 Turitea Board of Enquiry Decision Consent Conditions Members of the Board Glossary To download a copy of the evidence circulated prior to the hearing please click on any of the links below: Cultural Impact Assessment Cultural Impact Assessment prepared by Rangitane O Tamaki Nua A Rua Applicant hearing evidence Mark John Apeldoorn Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Transportation Effects) Peter Armstrong Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Wind Resource Assessment) David Black Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Potential Health Effects) Frant Boffa Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Landscape and Visual Effects Assessment) Albert Brantley Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Chief Executive - Genesis Power Ltd T/A Genesis Energy Ltd) Rodney Clough Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Archaeological Assessment) Neil Crampton Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Potential Effects on Groundwater) Ruth Johanna Goldsmith Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Aquatic Assessment) Robert James Greenaway Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Recreation and Tourism Assessment) Michael Miklin Halstead Primary 10 November 2011 (Acoustics - Noise) Jason Robert Hills Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Interference Effects to various Radio Communication Facilities) Richard John Matthews Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Applications Sought and Plan(s) Assessment) Timothy Michael McKenzie Primary Evidence 10 November (Project Design and Alternatives) Philip Hunter Mitchell Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Planning related issues) Stephanie Katherine Murphy Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Genesis Corporate Environmental Policy & Values, Overview of Project, Consultation with Tangata Whenua) Dr Ganesh Nana Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Economic Effects) Graham Nash Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Civil Engineering Assessment & Construction) Amy Elizabeth Rennell Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Genesis - Consultation) Roger Seyb Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Surface Water Issues, Hydrology Effects Assessment, Water Supply Assessment, Erosion and Sediment Control, Drainage and Water Supply) William Bruce Shaw Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Ecological Assessment) Lee Athol Wilson Primary Evidence 10 November 2011 (Electricity related Effects Assessment) Horizons Regional Council and Greater Wellington Regional Council evidence Annexure 1 – Further information letters, memos, email from Genesis dated 6 Sept, 21 Oct, and 28 Oct. Annexure 2 – Legal Descriptions Annexure 5 – Technical Hearings Report – Hydrology Annexure 6 – Technical Hearings Report – Aquatic Ecology Annexure 7 – Technical Hearings Report – Erosion and Sediment Control Annexure 8 – Technical Hearings Report – Terrestrial Ecology and Biodiversity Annexure 9 – Recommended Conditions Conditions relating to terrestrial ecology and indigenous biodiversity Tararua District Council and Masterton District Council planning evidence Section 42 planning report including Appendix A-D Appendix E - RMA s95E Affected Party Approval Forms Appendix F - Summary of Submissions You can also request a hard copy or CD of any/all of the hearing evidence from Perception Planning Ltd, on 06 306 6105 or by email to projects@perceptionplanning.co.nz.Hearing evidence